“Gradually, then suddenly,” is a quote by Hemingway that applies to politics. Six months ago, I would not have believed that free speech advocates could challenge censorship effectively. The Twitter Files had an impact but did not bring real accountability or change. Change is now expected in the US government and related sectors, depending on the new administration’s actions regarding free speech. I am hopeful they will make positive changes, especially given that censorship has targeted Trump and his allies. However, there is a risk that they might go too far, either by eliminating necessary safeguards or becoming censors themselves.
Musk's platform, X, has often contradicted its free speech claims, a trend I expect could continue with the new administration. Trump’s recent speech about dismantling censorship is hopeful, and my organization, liber-net, has proposals to address the Censorship-Industrial Complex. It remains uncertain how many promises will be delivered. Conversations about influential figures and potential appointments raise concern. Significant steps, such as cutting federal funding to “fact-checking” NGOs and anti-disinformation institutions, are crucial. Liber-net has been cataloging over 1,000 such initiatives and identifying federally funded ones.
The censorship situation is not just limited to the US; global funding is used by the federal government to support NGOs and academia that often stifle opposing views. While there may be legitimate anti-disinformation efforts, thorough and fair evaluation is key. The liberal and progressive censors may either learn from criticism or risk becoming less relevant. If they choose to reform, that would be a positive outcome, but a breakdown in dialogue makes continuity more likely.
Many potential reformers may stay silent due to fear of losing their positions. Academic spaces are often conformist, though some individuals have stood out against censorship. Recent comments from media commentators highlight disconnects and complicity in censorship, indicating deep-rooted issues in the system. Academic and NGO leaders have largely failed to show courage, and cutting federal funds may be vital in pushing necessary reforms.
The recent election reflects a rejection of the censorship regime. However, the fight for free speech is ongoing. Institutions must become arenas for open and honest discussions again.
https://brownstone.org/articles/free-speech-wins-the-culture-war/
No comments:
Post a Comment