This article discusses the speeches of Senator Bernie Sanders and Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC) during an event in Colorado. The author critiques their use of Marxist themes and terms, emphasizing that their rhetoric has not evolved over a century.
1. Marxist Rhetoric:
• AOC's speech echoed classic Marxist ideas by repeatedly mentioning the "working class" and "solidarity," aiming to provoke class resentment.
• Both AOC and Sanders employ terms associated with communism, likening modern struggles to historical contexts outlined in the Communist Manifesto.
2. Broad Definition of Working Class:
• The term "working class" now appears to include diverse groups such as the homeless and illegal migrants, creating tension among actual workers who feel their struggles differ.
• Workers express dissatisfaction with being grouped with those they believe do not share their responsibilities or aspirations.
3. Economic Criticism:
• Sanders's speech targeted wealth inequality and presented a pessimistic view of the economy, criticizing billionaires and large investment firms.
• However, Sanders did not address current inflation issues or the significant public debt resulting from years of spending, ignoring the fact that the top 1% of earners pay a large portion of taxes.
4. Historical Context:
• The language and ideas presented by Sanders and AOC reflect the sentiments of early socialist candidates like Eugene V. Debs, who advocated for worker solidarity.
• The author highlights that despite historical changes and the establishment of unions, modern leftist leaders still cling to outdated ideologies.
5. Critique of Modern Economic Reality:
• The article points out the historical failure of the Marxist viewpoint and criticizes Sanders and AOC for not adapting their beliefs to current economic realities.
• The author argues that their speeches represent a misguided political delusion that does not address the complexities of today's economy.
The author concludes that the speeches from Sanders and AOC are reminiscent of early 20th-century socialism, lacking relevance in today's political and economic landscape. Their reliance on outdated rhetoric suggests a disconnect from the progress and changes in society and economy since Debs's time.
https://www.frontpagemag.com/aoc-sanders-singing-the-same-old-marxist-song/
No comments:
Post a Comment