There Is Nothing Progressive About Progressives

The modern Progressive Movement, arguing that its practices and ideologies are regressive rather than progressive. It challenges the claim of progressives to embody future-oriented values and examines various aspects of their approach to society, culture, and politics.

1. Definition of Progressivism:

The article defines progressivism as a self-proclaimed movement that perceives itself as a protector of the future while marginalizing dissenters.

2. Regressive Nature of Ideas:

The author argues that modern progressive policies, especially around hiring and education, mimic outdated caste systems instead of promoting equality and freedom.

3. Restrictions on Free Speech:

It notes how progressives have reinstated restrictions on speech similar to ancient blasphemy laws, creating a set of doctrine that cannot be questioned, which leads to cancellation of dissenters.

4. Inherited Guilt and Privilege Pedagogy:

The idea that individuals bear moral debt based on their ancestors is seen as a harmful resurgence of historical notions of guilt. This new ideology demands continuous penance with no potential for redemption.

5. Shift from Universalism to Tribalism:

The shift from a universal understanding of truth to a perspective based on identity and feelings is depicted as a regression to tribal thinking, undermining human reason.

6. Economic Resurgence of Outdated Models:

The article critiques economic policies like rent control, suggesting they reflect ancient ideas of centralized price fixing, leading to predictable shortages and economic decline.

7. Historical Anti-Semitism:

Progressives are accused of reviving anti-Semitic ideas, repackaging old prejudices against Jews in contemporary forms, thus betraying their supposed values of justice and equality.

8. Societal Regression:

The author references Dr. Murray Bowen's perspective that chronic societal anxiety leads to emotional decision-making rather than principled choices, resulting in a loss of individuality and critical thinking.

The article concludes that the modern Progressive Movement is not truly progressive but rather a nostalgic movement yearning for the past. It reflects on historical lessons learned from societal regression and warns of the consequences of returning to old, harmful ideas. 

https://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2026/11/there-is-nothing-progressive-about-progressives/