Justice Clarence Thomas Is Right about Progressivism

 Justice Clarence Thomas recently criticized progressivism in a speech, calling it anti-American and a source of political oppression. This statement received backlash from progressive critics who claim that progressivism has led to necessary reforms in American society. The discussion revolves around the historical implications of progressivism and its responsibility for various societal issues.

1. Thomas's Critique on Progressivism:

• Thomas described progressivism as detrimental, linking it to authoritarian regimes in Europe, such as those led by Hitler and Stalin. He argued that progressivism has contributed to disasters in the U. S. and beyond while enabling harmful state actors.

2. Historical Misinterpretations:

• Critics argue that while Woodrow Wilson identified as a progressive, his presidency also included significant racial discrimination, limiting opportunities for Black Americans. Conversely, historians concede that progressives also played roles in civil rights advancements.

3. Progressivism and Jim Crow Laws:

• Many historians highlight that early progressives were instrumental in establishing the segregation policies associated with Jim Crow laws. Figures like Wilson and others promoted racial purity ideas, contributing to systemic racism.

4. Impact on World Events:

• The progressive reforms of the early 20th century, including changes in government and economic policies, are argued to have led indirectly to the Great Depression and the rise of authoritarian regimes in Europe.

• The Federal Reserve's role during the 1920s is cited as a contributor to the economic instability that led to the stock market crash of 1929.

5. Eugenics Movement:

• The American progressive movement included support for eugenics, promoting ideas of racial superiority that were later adopted by the Nazi regime. Prominent figures in the eugenics movement emerged from the Progressive Era, establishing a legacy of racial ideology.

6. Critique of Economic Policies:

• Critics argue that policies from both Herbert Hoover and Franklin Roosevelt were not laissez-faire but rather progressive interventions that exacerbated the economic crisis. The policies introduced during the Great Depression are said to have delayed recovery.

7. Continued Influence of Progressivism:

• The document suggests that modern manifestations of progressivism have evolved into movements like Democratic Socialism, which still seek to expand state power at the expense of individual liberties.

The criticisms posed by Clarence Thomas highlight a view that progressivism has had historically negative impacts, particularly regarding governance and social policies. Although some progressives attempted to reform earlier injustices, the roots of their ideology facilitated systems of oppression and persist in contemporary discussions. The legacy of progressivism, especially its ties to authoritarian practices and economic failures, shapes the ongoing political landscape.

https://mises.org/mises-wire/justice-clarence-thomas-right-about-progressivism