Friday, November 20, 2026

No Vote Created the National ID. Now Comes the Wallet, the Face and the Passport

 From Staff

The announcement that the State Department will pilot online applications for new passports, including for children, is being reported as a customer service story. It is better understood as the latest installment in a ninety year project that no American legislature ever approved in the open.

On November 16 the department published notice of a pilot for an online version of Form DS 11, the application used by people who have never held a passport. The process is described in plain regulatory language. An applicant opens an account at Login.gov, provides an identification document, passes a liveness check that captures a live photograph through the camera, submits to facial recognition comparison against the document, enters a Social Security number and an address. Then has that verified profile transmitted to the State Department.

That is not a form on a website. It is an enrollment in a federal identity account, authenticated by the one number every American is issued at birth and secured by a face that cannot be reset.

The Social Security number was created in 1935 to track earnings for benefit calculations. It was never intended to prove who someone is. The issuing agency has said so itself, repeatedly, in its own published history.

The drift began in 1943, when an executive order directed federal agencies to use the number as an identifier in new record systems. It accelerated in 1962, when the Internal Revenue Service adopted it as the official taxpayer identification number. It widened in 1965 with Medicare and again in 1970, when the Bank Secrecy Act required banks, savings institutions, credit unions and broker dealers to collect the number from every customer.

By 1971 an internal task force recommended that the agency do nothing to promote the number as an identifier. A 1973 report from the Department of Health, Education and Welfare concluded that a national identifier was not desirable and that the Social Security number was unsuitable for the purpose. Both findings were set aside without debate.

Then came 1986. The Tax Reform Act required taxpayers to list the number of every dependent age five or older. The Immigration Reform and Control Act allowed the card to establish employment eligibility. The age floor for dependents was lowered over time until it reached birth. Every American infant now receives a federal tracking number before leaving the hospital.

The only genuine legislative decision arrived in 2005. It was engineered to avoid scrutiny.

The Real ID Act passed the House as a standalone measure by 261 to 161 in February of that year. The Senate stripped it out of the underlying spending bill in April. It was then reinserted by the conference committee into emergency funding for the Iraq war and tsunami relief. The conference report passed the House 368 to 58 and the Senate by 100 to 0. President Bush signed it on May 11, 2005.

The Senate never debated Real ID as legislation. No committee held a hearing on it. It passed unanimously inside a bill no member could oppose without defunding troops and disaster relief. That is the template, and it has not changed in twenty years.

The project is now running on a schedule. Regulation 2024/1183, known as eIDAS 2, requires every European Union member state to offer a free digital identity wallet by December 24 of this year. By December 24, 2027, banks, energy providers, transport operators, health services, telecommunications firms, social security agencies, schools, postal services, water utilities and the largest online platforms must accept it.

Brussels calls use of the wallet voluntary for citizens. The distinction is formal rather than real. A credential that every bank, employer, insurer, landlord and platform is legally obliged to accept. It is being pushed to demand, is not a choice for the person who needs a bank account.

The Commission has also built a smaller companion app for age verification, issued on the same specifications and interoperable with the full wallet, with member states instructed to roll it out by the end of this year. Protecting children is a difficult thing to organize against. It puts the application on the phone and the issuing infrastructure in place.

The United Kingdom offers the clearest illustration of how these programs survive opposition. The government announced a national digital identity scheme, absorbed sustained criticism. In July of this year the incoming administration cancelled the Digital ID programme.

The cancellation removed a name. Everything underneath it continued. The Office for Digital Identities and Attributes still operates the statutory trust framework and the register of certified providers under the Data Use and Access Act of 2025. The GOV.UK One Login system, the GOV.UK Wallet, digital driving licences, digital veteran cards and certified digital right to work checks all proceed. The government's own response to a parliamentary committee confirms this arrangement in writing.

The announced program dies in daylight. The registry, the standards and the credentials are built in the shade. That is the identical pattern of the Social Security number, eight decades later.

There is no national digital identity statute in the United States. None is required.

Real ID enforcement began on May 7, 2025, bringing the federal gate into force. Mobile driver licenses are now live in roughly two dozen states, the District of Columbia and Puerto Rico. The Transportation Security Administration accepts them at airports under individual state waivers. Apple Wallet and Google Wallet are among the issued credentials, which places part of the national identity layer inside two private companies. A trade association operates the trust service that binds every state issuer into a single interoperable framework.

Meanwhile roughly half the states enforce age verification online, most requiring a government identification document or a facial scan uploaded to each individual website. Facial data collected at that scale does not stay separated from government records. There is no serious mechanism proposed to keep it separated.

The State Department's own numbers show why the passport route matters more than any of it. Online renewal began in a limited form in 2022, opened fully to the public in September 2024. By September of this year had processed about nine million renewals, more than half of all renewals nationwide.

The department is now proposing to extend online renewal to applicants living abroad, in phases. To relax the remaining validity requirement that had limited who could qualify. Reports also indicate the department intends to accept passport photographs taken at home for processing by facial recognition.

The old paper process, for all its friction, created no central biometric record and no federal identity account. The new one requires both. Renewal applicants surrender the number. New applicants, including children, surrender the number and a face. Login.gov becomes the broker that vouches for each of them to the rest of the government.

Civil liberties groups have pressed the objections for years. The American Civil Liberties Union has warned about systems designed to notify the issuer every time a credential is presented, turning each verification into a record of where, when and to whom a person identified themselves. The Electronic Frontier Foundation notes that a requirement to present identity several times a day accustoms people to their own surveillance. Researchers point out that central registries are catastrophic single points of failure, exposed to breach, leak and quiet interagency sharing.

Each objection is technically correct and each has been procedurally bypassed.

None of this requires believing that the people building it are villains. The convenience is genuine. The old system was genuinely miserable.

What remains to be decided is narrower and more important than any of the technical detail. Whether a paper passport application stays available. Whether a physical identification card remains sufficient on its own. Whether cash remains legal tender and a real option.

Keep those three and the digital layer is a choice. Remove any one of them and consent becomes a word used in a press release.

The record shows what happens next when nobody is watching. The number arrived without a vote. The card followed without a debate. The face is arriving during a conversation about wait times.

Sources:

Agency history stating the card was "never intended to serve as a personal identification document," plus the 1943 executive order, the 1971 task force and the 1973 departmental conclusion:
https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/ssb/v69n2/v69n2p55.html

  • Legislative history and the full vote record: passed the House 261 to 161 in February, appended to the Iraq and tsunami supplemental, House conference report 368 to 58, Senate conference report 100 to 0, signed May 11, 2005. Also the note that the Senate never discussed or voted on the act specifically and held no hearings:
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/REAL_ID_Act

  • Congressional Research Service report confirming the mechanism and that the Senate passed version did not contain the act:
    https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/RL32783.html


No comments: