Senator Tim Kaine Declares that Rights Come from Government

  Virginia Senator Tim Kaine expressed strong concern during a Senate hearing about the nomination of Riley Barnes, who claimed that individual rights come from God rather than the government. This raises questions about the nature and source of rights.

1. Kaine's Reaction: Kaine found it “extremely troubling” that Barnes believes rights originate from a Creator. He compared this view to beliefs held by the Iranian government, which bases its rule on religious law that targets minority groups.

2. Kaine's Belief: Although Kaine describes himself as a believer in natural rights, his stance seems to suggest that rights are essentially defined by government legislation rather than being inherent or God-given, as stated in the Declaration of Independence.

3. Historical Perspective: The Declaration of Independence asserts that human beings are endowed by their Creator with unalienable rights such as life and liberty. This idea of natural rights, historically linked to thinkers like John Locke and Thomas Aquinas, emphasizes that freedoms exist independently of government.

4. Danger of Government-Created Rights: Kaine's framework implies that the government could redefine or abolish these natural rights, which contradicts the classical liberal view that asserts rights exist inherently and the government's role is to protect them, not create them.

5. Implications on State Power: The classical liberal tradition argues that government historically has infringed upon individual rights. Hence, rights that are derived from a Creator stand in opposition to the expansion of state power, which a modern social democrat like Kaine might oppose.

The debate centers on the foundational source of rights: while Kaine suggests they are legislated by government, traditional views highlight that they are inherent and should not be subject to governmental alteration. This difference underscores broader ideological divides regarding the role of the state and individual freedoms.

https://mises.org/mises-wire/senator-tim-kaine-declares-rights-come-government