Sunday, September 17, 2023

Oral Argument In The Ninth Circuit Court Of Appeals In Health Freedom Defense Fund Et Al. V. Alberto Carvalho

What is the rational basis for saying that a vaccine mandated three years ago continues to work today? What if LAUSD is still requiring the shot twenty years from now, when there is no emergency? How did the school district come up with the premise that it doesn’t matter whether the shot is effective or not?

Oral argument in the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in Health Freedom Defense Fund.

The plaintiffs, Health Freedom Defense Fund, California Educators for Medical Freedom, and several individuals, are appealing the district court's dismissal of their lawsuit against the Los Angeles Unified School District's Covid-19 vaccine mandate.

The Ninth Circuit Court judges clearly understood this important fact.

The Ninth Circuit has the power to not only right these wrongs but to advance the constitutionally protected cause of freedom by affirming the appeal and sending the case back to district court for a proper adjudication of the facts.

Over the decades, when constitutional amendments have been challenged, the Supreme Court has made clear that no right is held more sacred than that of bodily autonomy.

A final note, after the Court had adjourned and our attorney and LAUSD's attorney, Connie Michaels, were walking through the gate from the argument lectern to the gallery, she turned and bitterly spat "What are you going to do when the board rescinds the policy!".

Let's hope LAUSD does not rescind the mandate, and if it does, let's hope the court does not fall for it. 

https://brownstone.org/articles/oral-argument-in-the-ninth-circuit-court-of-appeals-in-health-freedom-defense-fund-et-al-v-alberto-carvalho/

No comments: