In the wake of Mitt Romney’s defeat, many on the right, from Charles Krauthammer to Sean Hannity,
have argued that Republican resistance to amnesty for illegal
immigrants imperils the party’s standing with “Hispanics.” Simply grant
an amnesty, they say, keep every other policy the same, and Republicans
will sweep to victory in 2016. However, it could just as easily be
argued that class contributed more than ethnicity to Romney’s defeat.
According to exit polls,
Romney improved on John McCain’s national performance among households
making under $30,000 a year and over $50,000 a year (though he still
decisively lost those making under $30,000 a year). However, for those
households making between $30,000 and $49,999, he underperformed: McCain
lost those voters by twelve points, while Romney lost them by 15.
Moreover, because of the economic travails of the past four years,
members of those working-class/lower-middle-class households rose from
19 percent of the electorate in 2008 to 21 percent in 2012. Meanwhile,
members of households making under $30,000 a year rose from 18 percent
of voters to 20 percent of voters. So the income segments of the
electorate in which Republicans perform worse have been growing, and,
among those on the economic edge, Republican electoral performance is
declining.
This trend was exaggerated in many swing states. In New Hampshire,
Obama went from winning the $30,000–$49,999 demographic by three points
in 2008 to winning it by 21 in 2012. In Ohio, the president went from an
8-point margin of victory to a 12-point one in that demographic. In
Virginia, his margin went from ten points to 22; in Colorado, from three
points to 23. In Nevada, McCain lost that economic category by 18, but
Romney lost it by 36, and, in Pennsylvania, the gap between Obama and
his Republican opponent grew from 17 to 23 points. And not all these
changes can be traced to changes in the ethnic composition of the
electorate. In Virginia, for example, the Hispanic portion of the vote
remained the same, as did the president’s victory margin among
Hispanics, but Romney still lost considerable ground among working-class
voters.Read more: http://www.nationalreview.com/articles/333254/it-s-income-not-ethnicity-fred-bauer
No comments:
Post a Comment