Roger Kimball, the ethical teachings of Donald Trump are juxtaposed with the philosophical principles of Aristotle, particularly in relation to practical wisdom and common sense. While Trump’s lessons may seem simplistic compared to Aristotle’s detailed insights, they resonate with contemporary challenges and attitudes in modern society.
1. Comparison of Philosophies:
• Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics provides comprehensive wisdom about virtue and happiness.
• Trump’s teachings are more straightforward, highlighted in his video “Eleven Life-Changing Lessons,” which emphasizes key concepts like hard work and loving what you do.
2. Common Themes:
• Both Aristotle and Trump emphasize practical wisdom. Aristotle speaks of “phronesis,” while Trump refers to “common sense,” a term he prominently used in his speeches.
• Trump’s lessons encourage people to think big and work hard, reflecting similar ideals found in Aristotelian ethics.
3. Questioning "Common Sense":
• The article raises the question of who defines common sense in today’s society and notes the discrepancy between traditional values and some modern beliefs or practices, such as issues related to gender identity, immigration policies, and cultural celebrations.
• Examples are given to illustrate perceived failures of common sense in contemporary discussions on various topics.
4. Public Reaction:
• The media reaction to Trump's lessons is largely dismissive, with critics questioning his work ethic due to his enjoyment of leisure, such as golfing. However, the author argues that Trump has demonstrated consistent hard work and resilience throughout his career.
5. Life Lessons:
• Trump’s eleven lessons, while they might be criticized as simplistic, include valuable advice on personal responsibility and positivity. His urging people not to perceive themselves as victims resonates with practical wisdom.
• The lessons emphasize originality and the importance of self-confidence, culminating in the assertion that perseverance is critical.
Roger Kimball concludes that while Trump’s “Eleven Life-Changing Lessons” do not match the depth of Aristotelian ethics, they offer relevant and accessible wisdom for today's world. The lessons serve as a practical guide for personal development and resilience, making them noteworthy despite their simplicity.
No comments:
Post a Comment