For those who don’t follow military technology,
it’s a remote-controlled plane designed to fly at rooftop level,
equipped with a TV camera and missiles. The
operator, sitting in an air-conditioned office building in Nevada, can
control it anywhere on Earth via satellite uplink, seek out suspected
terrorists, and vaporize them. Does it work? Well,
it’s vaporized quite a few people; the Obama administration is even
more drone-happy than its feckless predecessor, and has been sending
swarms of drones around various corners of the Middle East to fire
missiles at a great many suspected terrorists.
You’ll notice that this has done little to stabilize the puppet
governments we’ve got in the Middle East these days, and even less to
decrease the rate at which American soldiers are getting shot and blown
up in Afghanistan. There’s a reason for that. The
targets for drone attacks have to be selected by ordinary intelligence
methods—terrorists don’t go around with little homing beacons on them,
you know—and ordinary intelligence methods have a relatively low
signal-to-noise ratio. As a
result, a lot of wedding parties and ordinary households get vaporized
on the suspicion that there might be a terrorist hiding in there
somewhere. Since tribal custom
in large parts of the Middle East makes blood vengeance on the murderers
of one’s family members an imperative duty, and there are all these
American soldiers conveniently stationed in Afghanistan—well, you can do
the math for yourself.
Thus the Predator drone isn’t a war-fighting technology, it’s a
war-losing technology, pursued with ever-increasing desperation by a
military and political establishment that has no idea what to do but
can’t bear the thought of doing nothing. The same logic drove the policy of torture so disingenuously defended by the Bush administration. (Yes,
waterboarding is torture. Anyone who wishes to disagree is welcome to
undergo the procedure themselves and then offer an informed opinion.)
Beyond the moral issues, there’s a practical point that’s far from
minor: torture doesn’t work. It’s
not an effective way of extracting accurate information from prisoners;
it’s an effective way of making prisoners say what the torturer wants
to hear—I recall the comment of the elderly Knight Templar, after his
session on the rack, that in order to get his torturers to stop he would
readily have confessed to murdering God.
No comments:
Post a Comment