The ongoing debate about deflation and inflation, arguing that deflation can be beneficial to the economy. The author, John McKearn, critiques mainstream economic views that frame deflation negatively and points out historical contexts and policies that have contributed to a decline in purchasing power.
1. Purchasing Power Decline: Since 1913, the dollar has lost 96-97% of its purchasing power. This decline is attributed to specific policy choices rather than natural market forces.
2. Historical Context of Prices: Prior to the 20th century, the U. S. experienced minimal inflation; prices often fell due to technological advancements and increased productivity. This period is referred to as "good deflation," where prices decreased naturally, allowing consumers to purchase more with the same amount of money.
3. Impact of the Great Depression: The Great Depression caused policymakers to associate deflation with economic collapse. The author argues that the Depression was exacerbated by poor governmental decisions rather than market forces, leading to a misconception that deflation is inherently dangerous.
4. Mischaracterization of Deflation: The article highlights how deflation, which can result from increased efficiency and productivity, has been painted as a threat since the Depression. This has led to the belief that prices must always rise to ensure economic health.
5. Worker Productivity vs. Dollar Value: American workers are significantly more productive than in 1913, yet their dollar's purchasing power continues to diminish. This gap illustrates the disparity between productivity gains and the actual tangible benefits that workers experience.
6. Government Control of Money Supply: Beardsley Ruml’s assertions about government control over the money supply show that with a non-gold-backed currency, the government can spend extensively without public scrutiny or accountability. This situation allows inflation to act as a hidden tax affecting the value of citizens' dollars.
7. Consequences of Inflation: Rising costs in essential items like housing, healthcare, and education have outpaced general inflation, pushing many to become financially burdened even before entering the workforce. The rising costs in these sectors have been exacerbated by government involvement.
8. Wealth Redistribution: Inflation disproportionately benefits wealthier individuals who own assets while harming those who earn wages, making it a regressive form of taxation. This shift in wealth occurs invisibly compared to direct taxation.
9. Loss of Government Accountability: The article argues that inflation allows governments to bypass traditional democratic processes of taxation, leading to less accountability for public spending.
The article posits that the common negative perception of deflation overlooks its potential benefits derived from increased efficiency and productivity. By acknowledging historical contexts and the consequences of policy decisions surrounding monetary expansion, it urges a reevaluation of how deflation is viewed as part of a healthy economic landscape. Furthermore, it conveys serious concerns about the far-reaching effects of inflation on the economy and individual finances, emphasizing the need for awareness and scrutiny regarding government monetary policies.
No comments:
Post a Comment