Saturday, July 7, 2012

Subsidies Old and New The system Obamacare destroys

President Obama has one thing right: Obamacare will end the process by which insured patients, or those capable of paying from their own pockets (e.g., the rich Saudi princes who inhabit the best suites in our hospitals), subsidize patients who show up in the emergency room, are treated, and then cannot pay their bills. That raises the cost charged to insured and self-paying patients as hospitals recoup their bad debts from caring for the poor.
But let’s talk about what subsidization in health care is really like, or at least until now has been like. When I was a kid on the Lower East Side of New York City, the family doctor operated out of his apartment on the ground floor of what today would be called a brownstone. Some of his patients paid cash, at varying rates based on the doctor’s understanding of the financial circumstances of his neighbors. Those who were really strapped paid either in kind— chicken soup was one of the coins of choice—or not at all. Those in more comfortable circumstances paid fees somewhat higher than they otherwise would have been to support the neighborhood doctor. Call it subsidization.

No comments: